Ever get the feeling as you watch (American) shows progress from season to season that the more things change, the more they stay the same?
Well, that’s exactly how I felt when I watched Season 2 of the popular “Glee” show. After a year of missing out on Season 2, I thought I’d missed much. As it happens, after watching Season 2 continuously, I realized I hadn’t missed much, and that I was actually better off just watching the more entertaining re-caps at afterellen.com (which I did when I couldn’t get cable overseas).
Where to start?
Well, let’s start with the fact that nothing much has changed in Season 2 except for the appearance of new faces: Coach Shanon Beiste (Dot Marie Jones) who replaces jilted Ken Tanaka (Patrick Gallagher), Sam Evans (Chord Overstreet), who serves as love interest to not one, not two, but three Glee Club members – Quinn Fabray (Diana Agron), Santana Lopez (Naya Rivera) and Mercedes Jones (Amber Riley) (and who, incidentally, doesn’t really improve on the vocal stylings of the group, if there were any).
There’s also the guest appearances that confound and baffle: Gwyneth Paltrow as substitute teacher (does she even advance the plot at all?), Charice Pempengco (as Sunshine Corazon – word to the wise, NO ONE in the Philippines could be named Sunshine Corazon. Corazon is a first name, we usually have Latin/Hispanic sounding last names. Incidentally, I wanted more of Charice in Season 2, not less, because she’s a better singer than most of the Glee Club members), John Stamos (as Jemma May’s dysfunctional Emma Pillsbury’s love interest, Emma being Will Shuester’s love interest last season) who does nothing but look pretty, Coach Sue Sylvester’s mom (why?!?) and so on.
Next – the plot lines.There isn’t much here in way of originality or interesting/profound story lines. Fact of the matter is, if you are looking for better shows/movies (TV or on the big screen), you are better off watching (=gasp=) “High School Musical” (1, 2 and 3) because, as much as I hate to admit it, HSM is actually coherent and cohesive, and executed with professionalism and hard work. In fact, the subject of singing (and the request angst/confusion/glory of music and high school) were better explored in movies such as “Mr. Holland’s Opus”, “School of Rock” (yes, I loved that movie) and “Sister Act 2″ (yes, with a very young Lauryn Hill and that boy who sings that timeless classic, “Oh, Happy Day”). The list could go on and on, but you get my point. Suffice it to say that “Glee” Season 2, fails on so many levels.
Case in point:
Sue Sylvester (Jane Lynch) is still scheming to remove Will Schuester (Matthew Morrison) and his club from McKinley High and she will go to great lengths to do it, even so far as getting the loveable Principal Figgins fired and Schuester fired. Her Machiavellian machinations made for interesting fodder for Season 1, but that she would still be doing it, and doing it for 22 episodes in Season 2 (with a break from it when her sister inexplicably and randomly dies) is just tired, and borders on irritating.
Will Schuester is still in love with Emma, who is in love with dentist Carl (John Stamos), whilst Will is still being pursued by his ex-wife, Terry (Jessalyn Gilsig), who goes to annoying lengths by teaming up with Coach Sylvester to make Schuester leave Glee Club. I mean, seriously, this has got to be annoying. I found myself fastforwarding to these scenes – as there isn’t anything here I haven’t seen before.
Finn Hudson (Cory Monteith) is with Rachel Berry (Lea Michelle) but can’t get Quinn Fabray out of his mind, especially when Quinn starts dating Sam. So Finn gets back with Quinn, but towards the end of the season, Finn suddenly wants to get back with Rachel. I find that the most excruciating scenes/episodes in Season 2 of Glee have to do with Finn, Rachel, Quinn and (by extension) Sam, which is pretty much every episode – which is about 22 hours of my life I could never have gotten back had engineers not invented that wonderful device – the fast forward button on my DVD player. It’s always baffled me why Finn is in the Glee Club anyway, he’s a second-rate singer who can’t dance with a lead part in the series, a part that’s clearly undeserved except he has the looks for it. Supporting characters Noah Puckerman (Mark Salling), Artie Abrams (Kevin McHale), Santana, and Mercedes are infinitely better singers than he is, but I don’t understand why he keeps getting solos EVERY SINGLE episode and he doesn’t just get one or two solos, sometimes he gets in on the group singing,too! Finn’s character seems weak, indecisive, self-righteous and inexplicably lacking in balls – as when he couldn’t stand up to bully Dave Karofsky (Max Adler) when Dave bullies his stepbrother Kurt Hummel (Chris Colfer),when he can’t decide between Rachel and Quinn (or keep either girls).
Puckerman gets involved with Lauren Zizes (Ashley Fink), but didn’t he also get involved with Mercedes in Season 1?Artie has gone from mildly annoying to intensely annoying – the character is blah and unlikeable, like IKEA furniture and I wondered why he didn’t go, although it’s probably because of the minority quota this show seems to have.
They had auditions in Season 1, and they also did Auditions in Season 2 (it was the first episode, in fact) , which they also did in Season 3. They also did “Duets” in Season 1, but they also did “Duets” in season 2. There is also an episode dedicated to “Acceptance” with the song “Born This Way” by Lady Gaga, but they already did that in Season 1, with everyone dressing up as Lady Gaga, to the tune of “Bad Romance”.
The only bright spot here is the coming out of Santana Lopez as lesbian – although that kind of leaves question marks all over as well, as she did not give any indication at all that she actually played exclusively on only one team. If she played for any team, it was actually on both teams.Her journey though, through Fleetwood Mac’s “Landslide” and “Songbird” were quite touching, although I did not appreciate the lesbian stereotypes (Tribeca? hairdos? etc.). Then again, Hollywood has always had trouble dealing with lesbian/bisexual women’s coming out and staying out stories. I do not know why – although I suspect it has more to do with extended mysoginistic/sexist tropes on gay women in general.I did quite enjoy watching Santana’s scenes with Brittany.
Kurt’s budding romance with Blaine Anderson (Darren Criss) was also one of the highs of Season 2, and in fact, this is the reason why I wondered why they couldn’t get the gay women coming out storyline. They handled this one with sensitivity and tenderness.
Aside from that, there was much randomness all around. A Britney Spears episode?!? Check. The football team has a half-time part where they sing and dance with both the Cheerios and the Glee Club? Check. Guest characters randomly appearing out of nowhere? Check. And also, towards the Season finale – the Glee Club gets to the Nationals, with no song, no practice, no nothing, and wonder why they lose.
Convoluted, incoherent, confounding, annoying, Glee has lost the steam (and originality) to actually sustain a show that is about musicals. You are better off hunting down better shows than this one. For a more layered, sensitive portrayal of angsty high school teens, you don’t need to look farther than “Buffy”.
Glee Season 2 has failed to deliver.
It is one of the shows that’s stayed on air longer than it should.